Planning a trip in Italy
Here is a quick example of using ChatGPT, Bard, and Claude as trip planners. I used the following as a prompt, then copy-pasted the results into ChatGPT and asked it to present them in a table and compare them.
The idea of the following is to see how the various AIs handle the request without any particular expertise in asking the questions. The results all appear to be practical suggestions; the issue becomes fine-tuning the results to meet personal preferences. For example, it would be possible to take into consideration the weather expectations for different areas.
Instruction
Act as a tour agent. We would like to take a 10 day tour of some of the top historical sites in Italy, we will travel by train and have a budget of $2,000. Can you suggest an itinerary.
Results
Each of the AIs provided a basic day-by-day agenda, I show the ChatGPT one in its entirety, then a summary table of the results and a comparison prepared by ChatGPT.
ChatGPT
Of course! Italy is a treasure trove of historical sites, and a 10-day tour will allow you to see some of the most iconic places. Given your preferences for train travel and the budget constraint, I have curated a 10-day itinerary for you:
Day 1: Rome
Morning: Arrive in Rome.
Afternoon: Visit the Colosseum and the Roman Forum.
Evening: Stroll around the Piazza Navona and the Pantheon.
Day 2: Rome
Morning: Explore the Vatican City - St. Peter's Basilica and the Vatican Museums, including the Sistine Chapel.
Afternoon: Visit the Spanish Steps and Trevi Fountain.
Evening: Night tour of Rome or relax in Trastevere.
Day 3: Florence
Morning: Take an early train from Rome to Florence (about 1.5 hours).
Afternoon: Visit the Florence Cathedral, Uffizi Gallery, and Ponte Vecchio.
Evening: Relax in Piazza della Signoria.
Day 4: Florence
Morning: Head to Accademia Gallery to see Michelangelo's David.
Afternoon: Explore the Palazzo Vecchio and Boboli Gardens.
Evening: Sunset at Piazzale Michelangelo.
Day 5: Pisa and Cinque Terre
Morning: Early train to Pisa (about 1 hour). Visit the Leaning Tower.
Afternoon: Continue by train to Cinque Terre (about 1.5 hours). Spend the afternoon exploring the beautiful villages.
Evening: Stay overnight in one of the Cinque Terre villages.
Day 6: Venice
Morning: Take an early train from Cinque Terre to Venice (about 4-5 hours).
Afternoon: Explore St. Mark's Square and Basilica, the Doge's Palace, and the Grand Canal.
Evening: Gondola ride.
Day 7: Venice
Morning: Visit the islands of Murano and Burano.
Afternoon: Explore the lesser-known areas of Venice and its canals.
Evening: Relax and enjoy Venetian cuisine.
Day 8: Milan
Morning: Train to Milan (about 2.5 hours).
Afternoon: Visit Milan Cathedral (Duomo), Galleria Vittorio Emanuele II, and Sforzesco Castle.
Evening: Attend a show at La Scala Theatre if possible.
Day 9: Verona
Morning: Take a day trip to Verona (about 1.5 hours by train from Milan). Explore the Arena, Juliet's House, and Piazza delle Erbe.
Afternoon: Relax by the Adige River or explore more of Verona's historic sites.
Evening: Return to Milan.
Day 10: Departure
Spend the morning shopping or exploring any last-minute attractions in Milan.
Depart from Milan.
Budget Notes:
Italy's rail network is efficient and reasonably priced, especially if you book tickets in advance.
Accommodation: Look for budget hotels or hostels. If you're willing to share rooms, it'll be cheaper.
Meals: Consider eating at local trattorias or purchasing ingredients from local markets to make your own meals.
I recommend purchasing a rail pass if you plan to travel by train extensively. The Eurail Italy Pass or the Trenitalia Pass might offer good value for your journey.
Remember to book tickets to major attractions in advance to avoid long lines. Enjoy your trip!
Summary Table
Here's the side-by-side summary table comparing the itineraries provided with the additional notes at the bottom:
Day | ChatGPT | ChatGPT & Bing | Bard | Claude |
1 | Rome: Colosseum, Roman Forum, Piazza Navona, Pantheon. | Rome: City center, Trevi Fountain, Pantheon, Spanish Steps. | Rome: City center, Trevi Fountain, Pantheon, Spanish Steps. | Rome: Ancient Rome sites. |
2 | Rome: Vatican City, Spanish Steps, Trevi Fountain. | Vatican City: St. Peter's Basilica, Vatican Museums, Sistine Chapel. | Rome: Colosseum, Roman Forum, Vatican City. | Rome: Vatican City. |
3 | Florence: Florence Cathedral, Uffizi Gallery, Ponte Vecchio. | Florence: Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore, Piazza della Signoria, Uffizi Gallery. | Pompeii & Herculaneum | Rome: Trevi Fountain, Spanish Steps, Pompeii. |
4 | Florence: Accademia Gallery, Palazzo Vecchio, Boboli Gardens. | Florence: Uffizi Gallery, Leaning Tower of Pisa. | Florence: Duomo, Uffizi Gallery, Ponte Vecchio. | Florence: Florence Cathedral, Piazzale Michelangelo. |
5 | Pisa & Cinque Terre: Leaning Tower and villages. | Florence: Day trip to Pisa. | Siena: Medieval city. | Florence: Uffizi and Accademia Gallery. |
6 | Venice: St. Mark's Square, Basilica, Doge's Palace. | Siena: Siena Cathedral, Piazza del Campo. | Venice: St. Mark's Basilica, Doge's Palace, Rialto Bridge. | Pisa & Lucca: Leaning Tower and city walls. |
7 | Venice: Murano, Burano. | Venice: St. Mark's Basilica, Doge's Palace, Grand Canal. | Venice: Gondola ride, Peggy Guggenheim Collection. | Venice: St. Mark's Square, Doge's Palace. |
8 | Milan: Milan Cathedral, Galleria Vittorio Emanuele II, Sforzesco Castle. | Venice: Mestre, mainland suburb. | Milan: Duomo di Milano. | Venice: Peggy Guggenheim Collection, Murano. |
9 | Verona: Arena, Juliet's House, Piazza delle Erbe. | Verona: Verona Arena, Juliet's House. | Milan: Santa Maria delle Grazie, Galleria Vittorio Emanuele II. | Verona: Juliet's balcony, city squares. |
10 | Milan: Last-minute attractions. Departure. | Milan: Milan Cathedral, Sforza Castle. Departure. | Depart from Milan | Rome: Departure. |
Notes:
ChatGPT: Consider staying in budget hotels or hostels. It's recommended to purchase a rail pass for extensive train travel, and tickets to major attractions should be booked in advance.
ChatGPT with Bing: Accommodations are budget-friendly hostels or guesthouses. A Eurail Italy Pass can be purchased for unlimited train travel. Look for city passes, like the Roma Pass or Firenze Card, which offer discounted entry to multiple attractions. Many museums and sites offer reduced or free admission on certain days.
BARD: This itinerary suggests customizing based on interests such as history or art. Savings can be achieved by traveling during the off-season, buying a travel pass for the train, staying in hostels/guesthouses, eating at local places, and leveraging free walking tours.
CLAUDE: Suggested accommodations are in 3-4 star hotels. The budget allows for train transportation between cities, entrance to major sites, with meals and gondola rides being extra costs.
Remember, prices and offerings can change over time, so always verify current details when planning.
Comparison
I asked ChatGPT to compare the results, it produced the following:
Heading | ChatGPT | ChatGPT & Bing | Bard | Claude |
Duration in Rome | 2 Days | 2 Days | 2 Days | 3 Days |
Vatican City | Part of Day 2 in Rome | Day 3 | Day 2 | Day 2 |
Duration in Florence | 2 Days | 2 Days | 1 Day | 2 Days |
Pisa | Day 5 as part of Cinque Terre trip | Day 5 during Florence stay | - | Day 6 during Florence stay |
Siena | - | Day 6 | - | - |
Duration in Venice | 2 Days | 2 Days | 1 Day | 2 Days |
Verona | Day 9 during Milan stay | Day 9 | - | Day 9 during Rome stay |
Milan | 1 Day (Day 10) | 1 Day (Day 10) | 2 Days | - |
Other Destinations | Cinque Terre (Day 5) | - | Pompeii & Herculaneum (Day 3) | Pompeii (Day 3), Lucca (Day 6) |
Cost-Saving Tips | Provided | Detailed | Provided | Provided |
Accommodation Recommendations | Budget hotels or hostels | Budget-friendly hostels or guesthouses | Hostels or guesthouses | 3-4 star hotels |
Transportation Recommendations | Rail pass and advance ticket booking | Eurail Italy Pass and advance ticket booking | Travel pass for the train | Train |
Unique Features | Cique Terre | Siena | Pompeii & Herculaneum | Lucca, Peggy Guggenheim Collection, Juliet's balcony |
Map
I asked Bard to show its results on a map:
It produced that together with a link to https://www.earthtrekkers.com/10-days-in-italy-itinerary/ which made me realize that Bard's suggestions were "borrowed". Of course all the AIs sourced their material from elsewhere but I hadn't expected this. It made me question the budget aspect.
Budget
I then started to try alternative budget scenarios. I asked Claude what budget I would need to stay in 4 or 5 star accommodation, the answer:
If you wanted to stay in 4 or 5 star hotels for your 10 day Italy trip, I would recommend budgeting approximately $3,500-$4,000. Here's a breakdown:
Train transportation between cities - $300
4-5 star hotel prices per night:
Rome - $200-300
Florence - $250-350
Venice - $300-400
10 nights at average $275/night = $2,750
Admission tickets for sites like the Vatican, Uffizi, etc - $300
Meals - $900 ($90/day)
Gondola ride - $100
So with 4-5 star accommodations, you'd be looking at around $4,000 total for 2 people. This allows you to stay in luxury hotels in prime locations and have comfortable travel between the cities. The major costs are the accommodations, but you'll also have higher quality meals.
Some ways to potentially lower the costs could be to look for deals on 5 star hotels, limit the number of fancy restaurant meals, or visit fewer paid attractions. But this budget gives you a good estimate for a luxury trip focused on comfort while seeing the top sights. Let me know if you need any other suggestions for making this dream trip a reality!
Food
A trip to Italy without planning for eating would be to miss out on a treat... as Claude expressed it:
Italy is famous for its incredible food and cuisine, so you really can't go wrong anywhere! But here are some of the top places I'd recommend to experience the best and most authentic Italian food on your trip:
Rome - Head to the Trastevere neighborhood to find some of the city's best trattorias and pizzerias. Favorites include Da Enzo, La Renella, and Dar Poeta. Also check out the fresh pasta, seafood, and produce at the Campo de' Fiori market.
Florence - The Mercato Centrale is an excellent spot to sample Tuscan dishes like ribollita soup, panzanella salad, and Florentine steaks. Make reservations for restaurants like Osteria dell'Enoteca or Il Santo Bevitore for delicious regional cuisine.
Venice - You'll find incredible seafood platters, risotto, and pasta dishes made fresh daily. Osteria Al Squero and Osteria Bancogiro are local favorites. Don't miss the Rialto Fish Market.
Bologna - Known for its rich food, try mortadella, Bolognese sauce, and tortellini. Tamburini is a great deli to try local meats and cheeses. Have an upscale meal at Trattoria Anna Maria.
Verona - The historic city center is filled with cafes and 'osterias' serving regional specialties from Northern Italy like polenta and risotto. Il Desco and Osteria Sottoriva are highly rated.
I'd also recommend joining a food tour in Rome, Florence or Bologna if you really want to dive into the country's incredible cuisine on your trip. Buon appetito! Let me know if you need any other Italy dining tips.
[I pointed out to Claude that Bologna was not on the itinerary, the response follows]
You're absolutely right, my apologies. Bologna was not included in the original 10 day Italy itinerary I suggested. Here are a couple options if you'd like to visit Bologna and sample some of the delicious food there:
Option 1:
Cut 1 night in Rome and 1 night in Venice. This would give you 2 days to spend in Bologna between Florence and Venice.
Option 2:
Take a day trip to Bologna while staying in Florence. It's only about an hour train ride between the two cities, so you could easily visit Bologna for the day.
I'd recommend Option 2 so you don't have to cut short your time in Rome or Venice. A day trip from Florence to Bologna would allow you to see the top sights like the Piazza Maggiore, Neptune Fountain, try some bolognese sauce and tortellini, and still be back in Florence for the evening.
If you do opt to spend 2 full days in Bologna on this itinerary, I'd suggest taking the train from Rome to Bologna, then Bologna to Florence, Florence to Venice, and ending in Rome. Let me know if you need help adjusting the itinerary - I'm happy to provide suggestions to ensure you get a chance to experience Bologna and the amazing food!
Closing Notes
The objective was to show an example of working with the various AIs for a topic like travel planning. I am going to discount Bard's borrowed map and certainly at this time neither ChatGPT nor Claude can produce a map graphic. No doubt these sorts of features will appear in the future.
I did ask Claude to suggest specific restaurants which it did without hesitation.
Comments